RECD Cleaning Quality Checks Before Returning a Generator to Service

The cleaned element is back from the workshop. The generator is waiting. Somebody wants it online by evening.

This is the moment where cleaning jobs quietly go wrong. Nothing has been proven yet, but the pressure to close the job is at its highest. The element has been refitted, the clamps are tight and the temptation is to start the engine, see that it runs and sign the job off.

A safer approach is to treat return to service as a gate with hold points: a short, ordered series of checks that must each pass before the next step. If a check fails, work stops at that point, and nobody argues later about when the problem began.

This guide sets out a four-gate routine for a cleaned RECD: paper, physical, cold and loaded run. Each gate has pass criteria, a named checker and a record. We explain what to compare against, give a worked example of loaded-run acceptance with numbers, set out a sign-off sheet and a role table and show how the routine connects to the checks on the cleaning report and to diagnosis if something fails. It applies equally to on-site and off-site cleaning, though some items matter more for one than the other.

As ever, the device manufacturer’s instruction governs. Where it differs from what follows, follow the manufacturer.

Why a gate, not a glance

Three common failure patterns the gate catches.

  1. Fitting errors. Elements refitted the wrong way round, gaskets omitted, clamps unevenly tightened, sensors in the wrong ports. US Environmental Protection Agency guidance on DPF maintenance points out that the filter must be reinstalled in the correct flow direction, and California Air Resources Board materials add that the element must never be reversed, that the engine must never be run without filter elements and that records must be kept. Those points are basic, and they are easy to get wrong when everyone is in a hurry.
  2. Damage in transit or handling. A returned element can be cracked in the box or dropped on the bench. Trade guidance advises inspecting a returned filter for shipping damage on receipt, before it is installed.
  3. Unresolved quality issues. The cleaning report passes, but nobody has checked that the element on the engine is the one in the report, or that the pressure at load matches the baseline.

The gate puts each of those checks at a fixed point. It adds perhaps an hour to a job, and it replaces the days of uncertainty that follow a poor start.

The four gates at a glance

GatePhaseQuestionHold if
Gate 1PaperIs this the right element with a complete, passing record?ID mismatch, missing figures, no verdict
Gate 2PhysicalIs it undamaged and fitted correctly?Damage, wrong direction, missing parts, leaks possible
Gate 3ColdDo the sensors and controls behave with the engine off?Fault codes, bad zero, odd temperatures
Gate 4Loaded runDoes the device behave as the clean baseline says?Pressure above tolerance, leaks, alarms

A fifth step, close-out, completes the record and releases the set.

Gate 1: paperwork

Before anyone touches the element, check the paper that came with it.

CheckPass condition
Element ID on the tag matches the ID on the cleaning report and your dispatch recordExact match
Report shows before and after weight and before and after flow or pressure drop, with units and conditionsPresent and legible
Reference value and acceptance limit are statedPresent
Verdict is stated“Within limit” or equivalent
Intake inspection findings and photographs are includedPresent
Waste record or statement is includedPresent
Any conditions or exceptions are notedRead and accepted, or queried
Quoted scope matches the work doneYes

If anything is missing, hold and ask the provider. Our guide to how to verify that an RECD cleaning service was effective lists the items a report should contain, and what an RECD cleaning quote should include shows what you should have agreed in advance. Remember that the report is a maintenance record, not an emissions test, a distinction explained in RECD cleaning certificates vs emissions test reports.

Gate 2: physical checks

Do these on receipt, then again as you refit.

On receipt

  • Packaging. Was the packing intact? Photograph any damage before unpacking. See packaging an ash-loaded filter for what good packing looks like.
  • Weight. Weigh the element, and compare with the post-cleaning weight on the report. A difference suggests moisture pick-up, damage or a different element. See how long a cleaned filter should dry before refitting.
  • Faces. Inspect both faces under good light for cracks, chips, glazing, displaced plugs. Compare with the intake photographs. Our guide to identifying cleaning damage shows what to look for.
  • Canning, mat and seals. Dents, loose wrap, damaged seal faces.
  • Dryness. The element should be dry to the touch and without an odour of solvent or damp. If it is not, hold.

If the element fails on receipt, you are back in the territory of when a provider should reject a filter, and you have a documented basis to send it back.

At refit

ItemCheck
Flow directionThe arrow or marking points the right way; the inlet face faces the engine side. Never reversed
Gaskets and sealsNew or sound, correctly seated, none omitted or doubled
Clamps and fastenersCorrect type, tightened evenly to the specified torque, in sequence
Heat shield and insulationRefitted as before; see insulation and heat shields
SensorsIn their tagged ports, with seals; see cleaning with or without removing sensors
Pressure tubesInlet to inlet, outlet to outlet, clipped, no kinks
HarnessOriginal route, away from hot parts, connectors latched; see cable routing near hot exhaust
Ports and plugsAll temporary plugs removed from ports; none left in the exhaust path
Tools and ragsCounted out, none left inside the housing

An Isuzu service bulletin on particulate filter cleaning makes two points relevant to this gate: that the heat shield must be reinstalled and that no regeneration is needed after cleaning. The first is an item on your list. The second is a reminder that a cleaned element does not need a forced burn-off to start with, so do not use regeneration to hide a problem. See requesting regeneration after cleaning for when it is and is not appropriate.

Hold point: a second person confirms flow direction and fastener torque before the unit is closed up. Two sets of eyes on the arrow cost seconds.

Gate 3: cold checks, engine off

With the unit assembled, power up the controller but do not start the engine.

CheckPass condition
Fault codes and alarmsNone active; any stored codes explained
Differential pressure reading, ports open to atmosphere (or as the manufacturer directs)At or very near zero; note the value
Temperature sensors with the engine coldClose to ambient and to each other
Heater circuit (if fitted)Continuity and supply per the manufacturer; no unexpected power
Harness and connectorsSecure; no chafing
Visual leak pathGaskets seated, clamps in place
Controller date, unit ID and settingsCorrect

The cold checks are cheap and catch many of the faults that otherwise show up as “the filter is blocked” an hour into a run. If the zero is off or two temperature sensors disagree by more than a few degrees at ambient, the problem is in the sensing system, not the filter. Our article on separating a sensor fault from an RECD performance problem helps interpret these results.

Hold point: no start until the cold checks pass and are recorded.

Gate 4: the loaded run

This is where the device proves it behaves like a clean one. Plan it, don’t improvise it.

Before the start

  • Check the clean-state baseline: the pressure drop recorded at a reference load when the element was new or last verified clean. If you do not have one, set one now and record it. Our guide on comparing RECD pressure readings at different generator loads shows how to choose load points, and RECD performance guarantees and operating conditions explains why the load and conditions must be stated.
  • Agree the load steps and hold time. For example 50%, 75% and 100% of the reference load, with a few minutes at each to stabilise.
  • Decide the tolerance. A common approach is to compare with the clean-state baseline at the same load, with an allowance agreed in advance (we use 10% in the example below, which is an assumption, not a standard).
  • Have an observer at the exhaust and another at the display.

During the run

  • Start and idle. Listen and look for exhaust leaks, rattles, smoke from joints and any alarm.
  • Step through the load points, recording pressure drop, inlet and outlet temperatures and any alarms at each.
  • Look and listen again at each step, particularly at the joints and sensor ports.
  • Watch for rapid changes. A pressure reading that climbs steadily at constant load is not stable.

After the run

  • Compare with baseline and tolerance.
  • Check joints and ports again for soot streaks that signal a leak.
  • Record the readings and observations.

A worked example: accept or hold?

The numbers are illustrative. The clean-state baseline and the readings after cleaning are as follows. The agreed tolerance is +10% over baseline.

LoadBaseline ΔP (mbar)Upper limit at +10%Run 1 readingVerdict
50%1717 × 1.10 = 18.718Pass
75%2828 × 1.10 = 30.829Pass
100%4040 × 1.10 = 44.041Pass

All three points are inside tolerance, with no leaks and no alarms, so the unit passes Gate 4.

Now suppose a different unit, with the same baseline, gives these readings.

LoadBaseline ΔP (mbar)Upper limitRun 2 readingExcess over baselineVerdict
50%1718.71919 ÷ 17 = 1.12, so +12%Hold
75%2830.83636 ÷ 28 = 1.29, so +29%Hold
100%4044.05252 ÷ 40 = 1.30, so +30%Hold

All three are above tolerance, and the excess grows with load. That pattern suggests flow restriction, for example residual ash or moisture in the element, a partially blocked pressure line giving false readings or an element that was not fully restored. It does not suggest “run it and see”. The set is held, and the diagnosis starts with the checks in what to do when pressure is high after an RECD cleaning service, beginning with the cold zero and the pressure lines, since those cost the least to check.

For the three-run comparison approach that complements this gate, see the cleaning report article linked above, which describes how repeated post-cleaning runs are compared.

Hold point: the set is released only when Gate 4 readings are inside tolerance, leaks are absent and alarms are clear.

Close-out and sign-off

Passing the gates is not the end. The close-out step turns the checks into a record.

  1. Complete the sign-off sheet (below).
  2. Update the cleaning ledger with the date, hours at cleaning and new baseline. The ledger supports decisions about intervals and service life.
  3. File the provider’s report, packing and custody sheets and photographs together, in the device’s evidence file.
  4. Record the waste handling and the container entry; see RECD ash collection containers: labelling and storage.
  5. Update the asset register and the shift handover log, so the next shift knows the filter was just cleaned and what the new baseline is.
  6. Brief the operators on what to watch in the first hours. See the alarm response matrix for operators.
  7. Decide on a follow-up reading, such as a pressure check after the first full-load run and again after a defined number of hours.

Where the cleaning was done in response to a warranty-relevant event, keep the evidence in the form described in what to record for an RECD warranty claim.

The first hours after release

Passing the gates does not mean the watching stops. For the first running period, ask the operator to do three simple things.

  1. Read and note the pressure drop at the reference load after the first full-load run, and again at a set interval, for example after 8 hours and after 24 hours. A reading that creeps up quickly after a clean start suggests moisture, loose debris or a line problem.
  2. Look at the joints once the system is hot. Soot streaks at a clamp or port show a leak that a cold check could not reveal.
  3. Write the readings in the handover log, so the next shift sees the trend and not just a single number.

If the first-day readings sit on the baseline and stay there, the new baseline is confirmed and the job can be closed with confidence.

A sign-off sheet

A one-page form works for every job.

SectionItemResultInitials / time
Gate 1 PaperElement ID matches record☐ Pass ☐ Hold
Report complete, with figures and verdict☐ Pass ☐ Hold
Gate 2 PhysicalReceipt inspection and weightWeight: ____ kg
Faces and canning undamaged☐ Pass ☐ Hold
Flow direction verified by second person☐ Pass ☐ HoldChecker: ____
Gaskets, clamps, torque☐ Pass ☐ Hold
Sensors, tubes, harness per tag sheet☐ Pass ☐ Hold
Plugs removed; tools counted☐ Pass ☐ Hold
Gate 3 ColdFault codes clear☐ Pass ☐ Hold
Pressure zero: ____ mbar☐ Pass ☐ Hold
Temperatures vs ambient☐ Pass ☐ Hold
Gate 4 Loaded runLoad steps and readingsTable attached
Within tolerance vs baseline☐ Pass ☐ Hold
Leaks, alarms, unusual noise☐ None ☐ Found
Close-outNew baseline recorded____ mbar at ____ load
Records filed☐ Done
ReleaseReleased byName / date / time

Who does what

TaskResponsibleAccountableConsultedInformed
Gate 1 paperwork checkMaintenance engineerMaintenance managerCleaning providerEHS
Gate 2 physical and refitTechnicianMaintenance engineerManufacturer instructionsShift supervisor
Flow-direction second checkSecond technician or engineerMaintenance engineer
Gate 3 cold checksTechnicianMaintenance engineerControls engineer
Gate 4 loaded runOperator with technicianMaintenance managerPlant manager (for load availability)Operations
Release decisionMaintenance managerPlant managerEHSShift supervisor
Records and wasteEHS or complianceCompliance leadProviderAuditor

Keep the release decision with a person who is not under pressure to restore the load. If the same person who needs the generator signs it off, they will find it hard to hold.

What to do if a gate fails

FailureFirst thoughtNext step
Wrong ID or missing reportMix-up or incomplete jobHold; contact the provider; do not fit
Damaged element on receiptTransit or cleaning damagePhotograph, notify, see the rejection guide
Element fitted backwardsHuman errorRefit correctly; inspect for harm; record
Zero reading offSensor, line or wiringCheck lines and connectors; swap test per the manufacturer
Temperature sensors disagree coldWrong port or faulty sensorCheck tag sheet; test sensor
Pressure over tolerance at loadResidual blockage, line fault, element not restoredFollow the high-pressure-after-cleaning diagnosis
Exhaust leak at jointGasket or clampStop; reseat; retighten; rerun
Alarm during runVariesUse the alarm response matrix; do not clear and continue

If a failure points to the cleaning itself, collect the evidence (readings, photographs, report) and put the problem to the provider in writing. A good provider welcomes a documented query. See RECD fault business continuity planning for keeping the set available while it is resolved, and for the case where a long outage follows, restarting an RECD DG set after long inactivity.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Starting the engine to see if it works.
  • Skipping the second-person check on flow direction.
  • Using regeneration to hide a poor cleaning result.
  • Having no baseline, so there is nothing to compare against.
  • Releasing the set under time pressure without Gate 4.
  • Filing nothing, so the next cleaning starts with no history.
  • Leaving plugs or tools in the housing.
  • Treating a high reading as a sensor problem before checking the zero and the lines.

Frequently asked questions

What checks should be done before returning a generator to service after RECD cleaning?

Check the paperwork against the element, inspect the element and refit, do cold checks on sensors and controls and then a loaded run compared with the clean-state baseline. Record each step.

Does a cleaned RECD filter need regeneration before use?

Generally not as a routine step, and some manufacturer bulletins say so directly. Regeneration is not a cure for a poorly cleaned element. Follow your manufacturer’s instruction.

How do I know the filter is fitted the right way round?

Look for the flow-direction marking on the element or housing, check it against the exhaust flow and have a second person confirm before closing the unit.

What pressure drop is acceptable after cleaning?

Compare with your own clean-state baseline at the same load, with a tolerance agreed in advance. A figure from another installation is not a reliable guide.

How long should the loaded run be?

Long enough to step through the load points and let readings stabilise, typically a few minutes at each point. Follow the manufacturer’s guidance and your own procedure.

Should the provider be present for the test run?

It helps on a first job or a dispute, because you can compare readings together, but it is not essential if your own checks are documented.

Closing thought

The cleaning is not finished when the element is back on the engine. It is finished when the unit has passed four gates and the record says so. Check the paper, check the part, check the sensors cold and check the pressure at load against a baseline you trust. Hold when a gate fails, and keep the release decision with someone who is not in a hurry. The routine adds about an hour, and turns a cleaning job into something you can show an auditor.

If you would like help building a return-to-service routine for your DG fleet, browse our retrofit emission control devices, see our certifications or contact the Aceget team.

Keep reading



Leave a Reply