- November 17, 2026
- Posted by: editor
- Category: RECD & Emission Control Devices
The element came back from cleaning in a clean crate with a clean report. The provider says it passed. Two weeks later, pressure at the reference load is a little lower than it should be, and a faint dark dusting has appeared on the inside of the outlet pipe. Did the cleaning damage the filter, or was the damage already there?
That question is very hard to answer after the fact. It is much easier to answer at the moment the element is unpacked, with the right light, the right pictures and a method for looking. This article is a field guide to cleaning damage on an RECD filter. It describes seven damage signatures, where to look for each, which cleaning stage tends to cause it, how serious it is and what to do next. It also gives you a four-level severity scale, a way of pairing photographs so that they prove when damage happened and a short example timeline showing how evidence settles a dispute.
A limit on what this guide can do. Inspection by eye finds the damage that is visible and says nothing about the damage that is not. Cracks can hide inside the ceramic. Acceptance criteria, such as how long a surface crack may be, belong to the supplier for your element. Use this guide to find problems and ask the right questions, and let the supplier decide what is acceptable.
Why inspection on return matters
Three reasons stand out.
Damage is cheapest to resolve early. At the moment of return, the provider still holds the evidence, the packaging and the memory of what happened. A month later, the element has been through heat cycles and handling, and nobody can say what caused what.
Damage can be invisible in the numbers. A cracked element can let exhaust bypass the filter, which may lower the pressure reading, so a “better-looking” pressure may hide a failure. A trade article on filter inspection explains that cracking can begin around the outer part of the brick and spread toward the centre without showing on the surface (Fleet Maintenance).
Particulate escapes quietly. A damaged element may still pass many tests while letting soot through. That has implications for both your engine and your compliance records.
Before you start: set up the inspection
You do not need a laboratory. You need a clean bench, good light and a camera.
| Item | Why |
|---|---|
| Clean, flat, padded bench | The element should rest on a cushioned surface; hard floors invite chips |
| Bright, movable light (torch or work lamp) | Cracks show as lines under raking light, and glazing shows as sheen |
| Second light source at a low angle | Raking light across a face shows steps, chips and unevenness |
| Magnifier (hand lens or phone macro) | A published bulletin notes that surface cracks are difficult to detect and a magnifying glass helps (NHTSA-filed service bulletin) |
| Scale reference (ruler, coin) | Lets later viewers judge size |
| Camera or phone with a fixed distance and angle | For before and after pairing |
| Gloves, eye protection, respirator, HEPA vacuum | Residual ash and soot may be present |
| Inspection sheet | Ties pictures to findings |
| Before photographs and the cleaning report | The comparison material |
Do not use a wire, pin or screwdriver in the cells unless the supplier’s procedure includes a pin gauge and you are trained. A pin forced past its depth mark damages the element, as the service bulletin cited above makes clear.
The seven damage signatures
Each card below has the same layout: what you see, where to look, which stage tends to cause it, how serious it is and what to do. Severity levels (S0 to S3) are explained afterwards.
Signature 1: Cracks
What you see. Fine lines across a face, crossing several cells, or a line running around the circumference. Horizontal (ring) cracks run across the brick, vertical cracks along its length. A truck-maker bulletin says a single crack running between one or two cells may be repairable, but a crack that extends along too many cells means the filter cannot be reconditioned (NHTSA-filed service bulletin).
Where to look. Both faces under raking light, and the outer rim where cracks often start. For internal cracks, inspect the outlet face for soot (see signature 5).
Which stage tends to cause it. Handling shocks (dropping, tapping, rough transport), thermal shock during a bake or fast cooling, excessive air or water pressure and mechanical contact with tools.
Typical severity. S2 to S3. Cracks are hard to judge by eye, so supplier assessment is needed.
What to do. Photograph, mark the location, stop and send the images to the supplier. Do not refit until the supplier has assessed it. See when a cleaning provider should reject an RECD filter for how rejection decisions are made.
Signature 2: Melted, fused or glazed regions
What you see. A glossy, glass-like patch, a lumpy or collapsed area, cells that look sealed or sintered, or a discoloured zone that feels different to a gloved fingertip. A published inspection guide groups fusion or melding of the substrate brick among the failure modes, ranging from localised internal hot spots to extensive exothermic breakdown (Fleet Maintenance).
Where to look. The outlet face first, because the hottest zone often lies deeper in the element, and then the inlet face. Look from several angles, since glaze catches the light.
Which stage tends to cause it. A thermal cleaning step that ran too hot or too fast, the burning of oily or fuel-soaked deposits in an oven, or an earlier thermal event in the engine that was already there. An equipment maker’s guidance warns that high-temperature baking without first clearing as much soot and ash as possible can ignite onboard fuel and heat the element near or above its melting point, causing permanent glazing (Fleet Maintenance).
Typical severity. S2 to S3. Melting is usually not repairable. A peer-reviewed study confirms that melts, pinholes and cracks have been found in both cordierite and silicon carbide substrates after uncontrolled regeneration conditions (Springer).
What to do. Check the provider’s thermal profile and trace against the report. See thermal cleaning of RECD filters: what owners should ask the provider. Compare with your “before” photographs. Glazing visible on the “before” photographs points to an earlier cause.
Signature 3: Gouges, chips and eroded faces
What you see. Missing pieces at the rim, scooped hollows in the face, loss of the end plugs that seal alternate cells, rounded or worn cell edges, or a face that looks pitted. A published truck inspection guide classifies the loss of substrate plugs across the surface as surface damage and sets numeric tolerances for the size and depth of gouges (Fleet Maintenance). Another notes that deep gouges can sometimes be patched with ceramic putty, though some are beyond repair (Fleet Maintenance).
Where to look. Rim edges, both faces, and the areas where handling tools would touch.
Which stage tends to cause it. A nozzle held too close, forced pins or probes, tools used in the cells, handling and transport knocks. Very high-pressure water can also damage a ceramic honeycomb, as the motoring article cited elsewhere notes (Jalopnik).
Typical severity. S1 for a small rim chip within the supplier’s tolerance, S2 to S3 for plug loss across the face. A missing plug lets gas bypass the wall.
What to do. Measure, photograph with a scale and ask the supplier whether it is within tolerance. One reconditioner’s published inspection list, for example, rejects cores with chips above a stated size and depth (Dinex). Your supplier’s numbers apply to your element.
Signature 4: A loose or displaced element
What you see. The ceramic sits further out or further in than it should, there is a gap at the can’s edge, the element rattles or moves when the can is tilted or the face is flush with the flange on one side and recessed on the other. A service bulletin says loose or displaced ceramic cannot be repaired, even if the movement is very small (NHTSA-filed service bulletin). Another source, a reconditioning guideline, accepts a pushed-out element as long as the substrate shows no damage, which shows that tolerance rules differ by maker (Dinex).
Where to look. The outlet-end clearance to the flange, the can for dents and the gap around the ceramic. Gentle tilt, listening for movement.
Which stage tends to cause it. A wet process that softens or washes out the mounting mat, an impact in handling or transport and over-pressure from air or water.
Typical severity. S2 to S3, because a loose element can crack, bypass or grind itself in service.
What to do. Record the clearance and compare with the “before” photograph. Ask the supplier to judge. A mat that no longer holds the element is a defect that the cleaning process, or the packing, should be asked to explain.
Signature 5: Soot on the outlet face
What you see. Black soot, sooty streaks or dusting on the clean (outlet) face of the element, on the inside of the outlet pipe or the downstream housing. A trade article on filter inspection states that soot on the back or outlet side is a telltale sign that the filter is internally cracked (Fleet Maintenance).
Where to look. The outlet face and downstream parts, in good light. A fresh, clean element should show no soot on the outlet face at all. Always know which side is which, using the flow arrow.
Which stage tends to cause it. It is a consequence, not a cause: a crack, a failed plug or a displaced element that lets soot bypass the wall. The cleaning stage that created the underlying damage is the issue, and you can only see it after the element has run.
Typical severity. S3, until the supplier shows otherwise.
What to do. Stop the set, photograph the outlet face, and compare with the clean “after” pictures the provider gave. If the outlet face was clean at return and sooty after running, you have strong evidence that the filter is no longer filtering. See separating a sensor fault from an RECD performance problem before concluding that the pressure reading itself is the issue.
Signature 6: Staining, discoloration and residue
What you see. Rust-coloured or chemical stains, white crusts or powder, oily patches, dark glossy films or a visible tide-mark where liquid dried. A reconditioner’s acceptance list says that cores with signs of chemical damage, such as stains from fluids, rust or other chemicals, cannot be reconditioned, nor can cores with oil staining (Dinex via Inter Cars). That is a reconditioning standard for remanufactured cores, so treat it as an example of a strict rule, not as a universal one.
Where to look. Both faces, the rim and the can’s interior, in raking light.
Which stage tends to cause it. Cleaning chemistry that was not rinsed out, mineral residue from wash water, deposits that were not removed (white residue is often ash) and drying that left a tide-mark. Oil staining may be pre-existing.
Typical severity. S0 to S2, depending on what it is and whether it blocks flow or harms a coating.
What to do. Identify what it is. Ask the provider for the chemistry and the rinse and drying records. See can you wash an RECD filter? and how long a cleaned filter should dry before refitting.
Signature 7: Can, flange, seal and port damage
What you see. Dents in the steel can, a distorted flange or clamping surface, scored gasket faces, stripped or cross-threaded sensor ports, bent brackets, a missing or crushed mat edge, dropped or damaged heat shields. A published guide treats dents beyond a set depth as can damage and distortion of the mating surface as flange damage, while accepting clamp witness marks unless rust could penetrate (Fleet Maintenance).
Where to look. The whole outside of the can, the sealing surfaces and every threaded port.
Which stage tends to cause it. Handling, tools, clamps over-tightened or struck and transport.
Typical severity. S1 to S2. These faults do not harm the ceramic, but they can cause leaks and false sensor readings.
What to do. Fix before refit, and log it. See what to record for an RECD warranty claim if parts or labour are in dispute.
The invisible signature: damage that eyes cannot see
Some damage leaves no visible trace. Two examples:
- Internal cracks that do not reach the faces. The outlet soot test and pressure behaviour are the clues.
- Coating degradation from heat or chemistry. Flow can look excellent while regeneration gets worse. See catalyst ageing and RECD regeneration behaviour.
The clues for both are in the numbers: a pressure that is lower than expected for the load, a weight that is lower than the clean, dry reference, soot downstream and regeneration that starts to struggle after the cleaning. Which brings us to the numbers.
Four clues from the numbers
| Clue | How to compute it | What it might mean |
|---|---|---|
| Pressure below baseline | (baseline − reading) ÷ baseline at the same reference load | Bypass through a crack or missing plug |
| Weight below clean dry reference | reference − weight after cleaning | Missing material (chips, eroded plugs) or a scale error |
| Weight at receipt versus packed weight | compare, allowing for packaging | Water uptake, lost debris or a different element |
| Test result better than any clean element | after-test pressure drop below reference | Bypass, a calibration error or an unusual test |
Worked example (illustrative). Baseline at the reference load is 32 mbar. After refit, the reading is 19 mbar. The shortfall is (32 − 19) ÷ 32 = 40.6% below baseline. That is not a good sign; it suggests gas is finding another path. A clean element should not read far below its own baseline.
Weight example. Clean dry reference is 13.50 kg. After cleaning, the provider reports 13.31 kg. The element is 0.19 kg below its dry reference, about 190 grams, or 1.4% (0.19 ÷ 13.50). Either the reference is wrong, the scale is off or some material has gone. Ask for photographs of the rim and faces and a retest.
A four-level severity scale
Use the same scale each time, so that findings can be compared across elements and cleanings.
| Level | Meaning | Action |
|---|---|---|
| S0 | No defect, or cosmetic only | Accept and record |
| S1 | Minor, within supplier tolerance, no effect on filtering | Accept with note, monitor |
| S2 | Possible effect on filtering or sealing, needs a decision | Hold refit, send evidence to supplier, repair or replace parts if allowed |
| S3 | Failure of filtering function or not repairable | Do not refit, claim and replace or re-assess |
Write the level on the inspection sheet beside each finding, and have a second person review any S2 or S3.
The photo-pairing method
Photographs are strongest when they are paired. A before picture and an after picture of the same spot, taken the same way, show change without argument.
- Choose fixed views. Inlet face, outlet face, rim at 12, 3, 6 and 9 o’clock, can side, flange, ports.
- Fix the distance and angle. Mark the distance with a ruler or a spacer. Use the same lens and light direction.
- Include a scale and a label with element ID and date in every picture.
- Shoot at each custody point. Before removal, before packing, at workshop intake, after cleaning, on return and after refit. See packaging an ash-loaded RECD filter for off-site cleaning for the custody route.
- Name files consistently. For example
DG3_elem_inlet_pre-removal_2026-11-14.jpg. - Put pairs side by side in a one-page comparison sheet.
A single pair showing a crack absent at workshop intake and present on return, with the same crate seal numbers recorded, tells the story.
An evidence timeline: how photographs settle a dispute
The following is an illustrative scenario, not a real case.
| Date | Custody point | Evidence | What it shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Nov | Before removal, site | Photographs of installed device and both faces | Faces intact; light ash on inlet |
| 4 Nov | Packing, site | Face photographs, tag sheet, seals A-7701/7702 | No visible cracks |
| 5 Nov | Intake, workshop | Photographs, weight 14.4 kg, flow 118 mbar | Faces intact, matches site photographs |
| 8 Nov | After cleaning, workshop | Photographs, weight 13.5 kg, flow 44 mbar | Faces intact, rim chip not visible |
| 9 Nov | Return packing, workshop | Seal numbers B-3301/3302 recorded | Pack sealed |
| 10 Nov | Return, site | Seals intact, photographs | Hairline crack visible on outlet face |
Reading the timeline. The crack is absent in four sets of pictures and present in the fifth. The seals were intact on delivery, which narrows the window to the workshop’s final handling and packing, or to the transport. The next question is which of the two, and the return packing photographs and the carrier’s custody sheet answer it. Without the pairs, the same crack would be an argument. With them, it is a narrow, answerable question, and the discussion shifts from blame to remedy under the order’s terms, such as replacement or a fresh cleaning.
What to do when you find damage
- Stop. Do not refit, do not run the set with the element in a doubtful state, and do not try a repair.
- Preserve the evidence. Keep the crate, packing and seals. Photograph everything.
- Notify the provider and the supplier the same day, in writing, with pictures and the inspection sheet.
- Ask for a joint inspection and a retest on the provider’s bench, with your representative present.
- Check the contract for responsibility, limits and remedies. If you did not write them in, see what an RECD cleaning service quote should include.
- Protect the DG set. Arrange cover if the set protects a critical load.
- Record the incident in the asset file and in the element’s ledger. See can repeated cleaning shorten an RECD filter’s service life? for how incidents affect lifecycle decisions.
- Do not clean it again until the cause is understood. A second process on a damaged element can make it worse.
For the wider return-to-service gate, see RECD cleaning quality checks before returning a generator to service.
Mistakes to avoid
- Inspecting only the inlet face. Many problems show on the outlet side.
- Poking cells with a wire to check for blockage.
- Skipping the “before” photographs, and so having no pair.
- Trusting a lower pressure as a sign of success.
- Signing the return without opening the crate.
- Debating cause before recording condition. Record first, argue later.
- Refitting “to see what happens”. A cracked element in service lets soot pass.
- Accepting verbal reassurance that a defect is “normal”.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my RECD filter is cracked?
By eye, you can sometimes see cracks on the faces under raking light, but internal cracks are hard to see. Soot on the outlet face is a strong indicator, as is pressure at the reference load that is unexpectedly low. Ask the supplier to inspect and bench test an element you suspect.
Is a small crack acceptable?
Only the supplier can say for your element. A truck-maker bulletin cited above treats a single crack between one or two cells as repairable, but anything extending along many cells as a reject. Other makers have different tolerances.
Can I tell whether the cleaning or the engine caused melting?
Compare with the “before” photographs and the provider’s thermal trace. Glazing visible before cleaning points to the engine or an earlier event. A clean “before” and a glazed “after” point to the cleaning, though only if the record supports it.
Who pays for damage found after cleaning?
That depends on your order, the provider’s terms and where the evidence places the damage. Record the condition at each custody point, and write responsibility into the order. See RECD warranty terms: parts, labour and exclusions.
Can a damaged element be repaired?
Some surface damage can be patched with ceramic putty according to trade sources, and minor defects may be repairable by specialists. Major cracks, melting and displacement generally are not. Do not attempt repairs yourself.
Does damage always show on the pressure reading?
No. A crack can lower pressure, a fused zone can raise it, and some damage changes neither. Combine pressure, weight, inspection and the outlet soot check.
The practical takeaway
Cleaning damage is easiest to find, and easiest to assign, when you look for it systematically at the moment of return. Set up good light, walk the seven signatures, apply the four number-based clues, grade each finding on the S0 to S3 scale and pair your photographs at every custody point. If you find damage, stop, preserve the evidence and bring the supplier and the provider in the same day.
If you would like help judging an inspection finding or planning an inspection routine, browse our retrofit emission control devices, read our FAQ or contact the Aceget team with your photographs and readings.
Keep reading
- When Should a Cleaning Provider Reject an RECD Filter?
- How to Package an Ash-Loaded RECD Filter for Off-Site Cleaning
- RECD Cleaning Report: How to Verify That the Service Was Effective
- Why RECD Pressure Can Stay High After a Cleaning Service
- RECD Delivery Inspection Checklist
- Silicon Carbide vs Cordierite RECD Filter Substrate
[…] for cracks, chips, glazing, displaced plugs. Compare with the intake photographs. Our guide to identifying cleaning damage shows what to look […]