RECD Malfunction After Generator Relocation: Hidden Installation Changes

Generators are moved more often than people admit. A project finishes and the set goes to the next plot. A plant room is rebuilt and the set shifts twenty metres. A building is sold and the DG set is carried to the new owner’s site. In each case there is a sensible plan, a crane, a transporter and a crew. And in many cases, a week later, the retrofit emission control device (RECD) is behaving strangely. Pressure is higher than it used to be. A sensor reads oddly. An alarm that never appeared before now appears twice a day.

The natural reaction is to say the move damaged something. Sometimes it did. But a relocation changes far more than the location. It changes the exhaust route, the supports, the length of cables and tubes, the ambient air, the fuel supply, the load the set serves and sometimes the person who looks after it. Most “malfunctions after relocation” come not from a damaged part but from a hidden change that nobody listed, because everyone assumed the set and its RECD were “the same equipment in a new place”.

This guide organises the search around three inventories: what departed with the set, what arrived at the new site and what everyone assumed had not changed. We then show which kinds of fault belong to which inventory, set out a first-week proving plan that turns a relocated set back into a verified one and finish with a worked scenario. If you are still planning a move, our article on planning an RECD for relocated generators on project sites covers the preparation. This article starts after the move, when something has gone wrong. As always, your supplier’s instructions and the engine maker’s manual take priority.

Why a move is a bigger event than it looks

Think of a relocated installation as a system that has been disassembled and rebuilt in a different environment. Even when only the set moved a few metres, the exhaust connections were broken and remade, supports were moved, cables and tubes were disconnected, and something about the surroundings changed. Each of those steps is a chance for a small deviation.

Manufacturers’ own installation and commissioning checklists reflect how much has to be re-verified after a set is placed. One generator maker’s pre-start checklist asks, among other things, that the set has a flexible connection to the engine and that supports do not load the turbocharger or manifold (Cummins pre-start checklist). Another commissioning procedure asks the installer to inspect exhaust flex connections, check mufflers and rain caps, confirm alignment of drive components and ensure all commissioning data is recorded (PSI commissioning procedure). A provincial master specification notes that the engine-generator alignment is set at the factory and should be checked after shipment and handling in case anything has changed (Newfoundland and Labrador master specification). These documents deal with the generator itself. An RECD adds more joints, sensors and settings that need the same discipline, and our guide to RECD commissioning with load bank testing shows how to do it.

The three inventories

Draw three columns on a sheet. Each will be filled with items, and each has different kinds of fault hiding in it.

Inventory 1: what departed

List everything that travelled with the set, and for each item note one of four states: reused as it was, replaced, left behind or lost.

ItemStateNotes
RECD canister (and was it removed from the exhaust for the move?)
Filter core (and was it transported inside the canister?)
Gaskets and seals at every opened joint
Flexible bellows and liners
Silencer and pipe sections
Support brackets, hangers and isolators
Insulation, heat shields and jackets
Pressure tubes, taps and fittings
Temperature probes and thermowells
Controller, heater, cabinet and cable looms
Rain cap, drain plugs, sampling-port caps
Fasteners and small hardware
Documentation, settings export, calibration records

The items most often missing from the second column are the humble ones: gaskets that were reused, fasteners that were substituted, tubes that were cut shorter and caps that were not refitted.

The canister and its core. If the RECD was removed from the exhaust and moved as a separate item, handling matters. A ceramic core is brittle, and a drop, a hard bump on a truck or lifting by the wrong points can crack it or loosen the mat that holds it. Our guide on packaging and transporting an RECD without damage describes the risks and the RECD delivery inspection checklist shows what to inspect on arrival. If the core moved inside the canister, a rattle or a change in ΔP may appear. See rattling inside an RECD for how to separate hardware from core damage.

Storage. If the RECD sat in a yard or a store between sites, moisture, dust, vermin and corrosion are possible. See storing an RECD before installation.

Inventory 2: what arrived

Now list what is new at the destination. These are the changes that nobody carried with the set, which makes them the hardest to see.

ItemOld siteNew siteEffect to consider
Exhaust route (length, bends, height, silencer)Back-pressure, temperature, heat loss
Support structure and foundationVibration, thermal growth, loading on joints
Sensing-tube length, slope and routingCondensate, response time, reading
Cable length and routing, earthingSignal noise, supply drop, faults
Power supply to controller and heaterVoltage dips, trips
Fuel tank, supplier, line lengthAir in fuel, contamination, pressure
Ambient temperature, humidity, dustCooling, condensation, loading
AltitudeAir density, exhaust flow
Ventilation and intake air pathRecirculation, heat soak
Load and duty (what the set now feeds)Light-load running, steps, frequent starts
Operators, service provider, proceduresTraining, response, records
Weather exposure (indoor, outdoor, canopy)Rain, sun, wind

Several of these have a large effect on an RECD.

The exhaust route. A different route means a different pressure budget. A longer run adds back-pressure and loses more heat, and a different silencer or extra bends changes both. Our guide to RECD exhaust bends, reducers and layout review explains why layout matters, and reusing existing exhaust pipework in an RECD retrofit covers what to check in pipework that came from somewhere else.

The supports. A set placed on a different foundation, with new isolators and different pipe supports, can load joints in ways the old installation never did. See wall-mounted versus floor-supported RECD support layouts and thermal expansion planning for RECD exhaust connections.

The duty. This one is often forgotten. A set that served a continuous factory load may now serve a standby role in a building where it runs a few hours a month, or the reverse. Light-load running and frequent starts change how an RECD behaves. See choosing an RECD for a generator running at low load and selecting an RECD for DG sets with frequent short start-stop cycles.

The environment. A move from an indoor plant room to an open yard, or from a dry inland site to a humid coastal one, changes moisture, dust and temperature. See RECD faults that appear only in wet weather, choosing an RECD for dusty industrial locations and coastal, salt-laden environments.

Inventory 3: what was assumed

This column is where the surprises live. List every statement that people made, or implied, about the relocated installation, and ask how each is known.

  • “The settings are the same.” Were they exported before the move and checked after? Many controllers reset to defaults after a long power loss.
  • “The alarm limits are still right.” They were set for the old exhaust route and old duty. With a different route, the right limits at a reference load may differ.
  • “The sensors are calibrated.” Calibration certificates may be out of date, or the sensors may have been knocked in transit.
  • “The filter is undamaged.” Was it inspected on arrival, and how?
  • “The tubes are the same.” Were they cut, shortened, re-run or replaced?
  • “The RECD suits the new duty.” It was selected for the old one.
  • “The drawings are current.” The general arrangement drawing describes the old installation. See what a general arrangement drawing should include and updating drawings and records after exhaust modifications.
  • “The approvals still apply.” Registration, consent or test certificates may be tied to a location, a configuration or a measurement made at a specific site. Check with the supplier and the relevant authority, not by assumption. Our guide to when to retest an RECD after DG set changes covers what changes may call for a new test.
  • “The asset records are right.” Serial numbers, locations and service histories should follow the set. See an RECD asset register for a multi-site DG fleet.

For each assumption, write one of three answers: verified (with evidence), unverified or known to be false. The unverified list is your to-do list.

Matching symptoms to inventories

Once the three columns have been filled in, symptoms can be matched to the likely source.

Symptom after the moveLikely inventoryFirst checks
Higher ΔP or total back-pressure than before, from the first runArrived (new exhaust route) or Departed (damaged or mis-fitted part)Pressure budget by section; core inspection; gaskets and reducers
High reading that disagrees with a portable gaugeDeparted (tubes, taps, probes) or Assumed (calibration)Sensing chain, tube routing and length, instrument check
Leaks, soot streaks, tickingDeparted (reused gaskets, fasteners) or Arrived (supports loading joints)Cold re-torque, supports, bellows alignment
Rattle or new noiseDeparted (core or mat), Arrived (support or isolator)Layered rattle checks
Alarms at start-up or on rainArrived (new tube slope, new exposure)Tube slope, glands, cabinet heaters
Heater trips or controller resetsArrived (supply, earthing)Supply voltage at the cabinet during heater and cranking
Faster cloggingArrived (new duty, fuel, oil) or Assumed (suitability)Load bands, fuel source, oil consumption
Smoke after restartDeparted (core, bypass), Arrived (fuel)Smoke timing, pressure, deposit checks
Controller shows wrong time, odd readings or defaultsAssumed (settings)Settings export versus current
Faults on only one of several relocated setsCompare the setsTwin comparison

If more than one inventory fits, test the cheapest inventory first. Assumptions and sensing chains are cheaper to check than a core.

The first-week proving plan

A relocated set should be treated as a new installation until it has been proved. The plan below, built around a baseline, turns a hopeful restart into a verified one. Adapt the details to your supplier’s procedures.

Day 0: before the first start

  1. Inspect on arrival. Canister, core inlet and outlet faces, gaskets, bellows and cables, using the delivery checklist.
  2. Compare the as-built exhaust with a drawing, measuring pipe diameters, bends and fittings.
  3. Check supports and flexible connections. The pipe should not load the turbocharger, manifold or the RECD flange.
  4. Check sensing taps and tubes. Correct connection, slope, no kinks, no heat contact.
  5. Check electrical supply and earthing, heater breaker ratings and controller supply.
  6. Restore or verify settings against the pre-move export.
  7. Check fuel, oil and coolant levels, bleed air from the fuel system and check for leaks.
  8. Photograph everything for the new record.

Day 1: first start and first loaded run

  1. Start and watch. Look and listen for leaks, noise and smoke at start. Watch ΔP, temperatures, heater behaviour and alarms.
  2. Run a staged load, for example 25, 50, 75 and 100% of what the site can safely provide, with a load bank if needed. Record at each stage: ΔP, total back-pressure if tapped, inlet and outlet temperatures, controller supply voltage and heater current.
  3. Compare with an independent gauge at each stage.
  4. Re-torque joints after the first heat cycle, as the supplier advises, and inspect for new soot streaks when cool.

Days 2 to 7: watch and adjust

  1. Daily checks: ΔP at a reference load, alarms, drains and a quick walk-round.
  2. Check the first cold start and first outage-driven start on the new site, and the first rain if it comes.
  3. Log duty: run hours, starts, load bands.
  4. Write any anomaly on a complaint card. See planning better intermittent-fault records.

End of week or after the first month: re-baseline

  1. Record a new baseline: ΔP and temperatures at three loads, regeneration profile if one has run, heater current and back-pressure.
  2. Compare with the pre-move baseline, if one exists, and explain every difference.
  3. Review alarm limits with the supplier in the light of the new exhaust route and duty.
  4. Update the drawing, asset register and service plan with the new location, route and findings.
  5. Decide whether a retest is needed. See when to retest an RECD after DG set changes.

If you skipped a pre-move baseline, begin one now. It will serve every future move.

A worked illustration: the 40 metres

The following is an illustrative scenario, not a real customer. A pharmaceutical plant moves its 500 kVA set, with an RECD, forty metres to a new utility yard as part of an expansion. The contractor detaches the exhaust at the turbo outlet flange, lifts the set on its skid and refits it. The RECD canister is lifted separately and re-fitted on a new frame. A week later, the controller reports ΔP at 60% load of 42 mbar against 31 mbar before the move, and a high-pressure alarm appears at start-up on wet mornings.

The inventories.

  • Departed: the canister was lifted by its lifting lugs (correct) and kept upright. Gaskets were reused at four flanges. The sensing tubes were disconnected and refitted, with one shortened.
  • Arrived: the new exhaust route is 14 metres longer with two additional 90-degree bends and a smaller silencer. The canister now stands outdoors under a roof with no side walls. The new supply to the controller comes through a longer cable.
  • Assumed: the alarm limits are right (they were set for the old route), the drawing is current (it is not) and the filter was undamaged (not inspected).

The tests. A portable gauge at the same taps reads 33 mbar at 60% load, close to the old figure, so the filter itself is probably unchanged. The controller reads about 9 mbar higher. The pressure budget across the new route shows that total back-pressure at the engine is higher than before, from the added pipe and bends, but still within the engine’s limit.

The findings.

  1. The shortened sensing tube was re-fitted with a sag, and on wet mornings it holds condensate, giving a false rise at start-up. Re-routing it removes the controller’s 9 mbar excess.
  2. The new route’s extra back-pressure is real but within limits. The supplier recommends keeping it under review and shows how to confirm it at rated load.
  3. Two reused gaskets show soot streaks after the first loaded run. The team replaces them.
  4. The drawing and asset record are updated, and the alarm limits are reviewed with the supplier based on the new baseline.

The “malfunction” was a mix of a sensing-tube error from the move, a real but acceptable change in route and two reused gaskets. None of these would have been found by blaming the filter, and the three inventories separated them.

Preparing the next move

  • Take a pre-move baseline and export the settings.
  • Photograph every joint, tap, tube and cable before disconnecting.
  • Label tubes and cables.
  • Order new gaskets and fasteners for every joint you will open.
  • Plan the new exhaust route with a pressure budget, and confirm that the engine’s limit is met.
  • Lift and transport the RECD as the supplier directs, and inspect on arrival.
  • Decide in advance who signs off the proving plan.

Questions people ask

Does moving a generator void the RECD warranty?

That depends on the terms. Many warranties assume the installation is as supplied, and a relocation may be a change that needs the supplier’s agreement. Check before you move. See RECD warranty terms: parts, labour and exclusions.

Do I need a new emission test after relocation?

It depends on the regulation, the permit and the extent of the change. Ask the supplier and the relevant authority, and keep a record of the answer.

Can the same RECD be fitted to a different set at the new site?

Sometimes, subject to engine data and sizing. See can an RECD be transferred to another diesel generator.

Should the filter core be replaced after every move?

Not automatically. Inspect on arrival, compare ΔP with the baseline, and replace if inspection or data point to damage.

What if no pre-move records exist?

Start a baseline now, use the supplier’s commissioning data as the reference and treat the first month as a proving period.

Summing up

A relocated RECD is an old device in a new installation. The trouble rarely comes from the move alone. It comes from the hidden differences: the reused gasket, the shortened tube, the longer exhaust route, the new duty, the setting that nobody re-checked. Fill in the three inventories, match symptoms to them, run a first-week proving plan and record a new baseline. If you would like help auditing a relocation or comparing before-and-after readings, see our retrofit emission control devices, the FAQ or contact the Aceget team.

Related Reading

Sources



Leave a Reply