Why Does an RECD Smell Different After a Service Visit?

The technician has gone, the paperwork is signed and the DG set is back in service. An hour later someone in the plant room says it: “It smells different.” Maybe it is sharper, or sweeter, or like something is burning. Nobody can say whether it is a harmless leftover from the visit or the first sign of a mistake.

Smell is a poor measuring instrument but a quick warning system. After a service visit to a retrofit emission control device (RECD), a change of smell almost always has a cause that comes from the visit itself: something was cleaned, replaced, sealed, lubricated or reassembled, and the first heat cycles drive off whatever was left behind. Most of these smells fade within hours. A few do not, and those are the ones worth catching.

This article is a smell dictionary and a timeline. First we explain the change list idea, which ties every smell to something that happened during the visit. Then we go through the smells one by one, set out what is normal in the first hour, the first day and the first week, and draw a clear line between “wait and watch”, “recheck” and “act now”. A safety point comes first and must be said plainly: carbon monoxide has no smell, so you cannot use your nose to judge whether an exhaust leak is dangerous.

The change list: what did the visit change?

Every post-service smell has a source, and the source is almost always on the visit’s work list. Before you try to decode a smell, write down what was touched. A good service report records it, and if yours does not, ask. Our guide to auditing an RECD service report for missing information explains what a complete report contains.

Work done during the visitMaterials involvedSmells this can leave
Filter core removed and cleanedWater, detergents, solvents, compressed air, thermal treatmentChemical or soapy smell, “baked” or scorched smell as residue burns off
Filter core replacedNew ceramic, new catalyst coating, new matSharp “new part” smell, mild burning as binders and coatings burn off
Gaskets and seals replacedFibre or graphite gaskets, metal sealsMild burnt smell as gasket binder cures
Sealants or pastes used (where approved)High-temperature sealant, anti-seize compoundSharp chemical smell, then burnt smell as they cure
Bolts lubricatedAnti-seize, penetrating oilOily burning smell, light smoke
Insulation or heat shields refitted or replacedMineral wool, fibreglass, bindersDusty or acrid smell; binder burning for the first hours
Sensors replaced or recalibratedThread sealants, cable insulationSlight plastic or rubber smell
Heater or controller workElectrical connections, insulationHot electrical smell is a warning, not a normal burn-off
Engine work done at the same timeOil, fuel, coolant, cleaning fluidsRaw diesel, oil or coolant odours
Drains and silencer cleanedSolvents, condensateSharp, sour or oily smell
Regeneration run after serviceSoot, oily soot, residuesHot, acrid smell during the cycle

If none of the work items could produce your smell, treat it with more suspicion. A smell that no change explains may be a mistake or a fault.

The smell dictionary

Smells are hard to describe, so each entry below gives the common words people use, the usual source, how long it should last and what to check. These are tendencies. If anything on this list also comes with smoke, an alarm, a rising temperature or a change in readings, treat it as more serious.

“Hot metal” or “new paint”

Usual source. The first heat cycles after the visit. New or freshly painted parts, protective oil films on new components, and residues on newly cleaned metal burn off. This is the most common and least worrying smell.

Typical duration. A few hours of running at temperature. It may return on the first loaded run after a long stop, then fade.

Check. Whether the smell is strongest near a new part. Whether it fades on a second and third run.

“Burnt dust” or “scorched fibre”

Usual source. New or disturbed insulation. Binders in mineral wool and similar materials burn at first heating, and disturbed old insulation can release a smell of burnt dust. Our guide on RECD insulation and heat shields explains the materials.

Typical duration. Hours to a couple of days.

Check. That insulation is not touching oil or fuel, and that no loose fibre is sitting on hot surfaces. A dusty smell that persists beyond a few days suggests insulation is soaked or contaminated; see the “damp and musty” entry below.

“Sharp chemical” or “solvent”

Usual source. Cleaning agents or solvents that were not fully flushed or dried, or a sealant paste that is still curing. A filter that was cleaned with liquid and not dried properly can release a chemical smell as the residual liquid is driven off in the first hot cycles. Our article on what to expect after RECD cleaning covers the first cycles after a clean.

Typical duration. The first one to three loaded runs.

Check. Whether the service report describes the cleaning method and the drying step. If the smell is strong, persists beyond several hours of hot running, or is accompanied by white vapour, ask the service company what was used and whether the filter was fully dried.

“Oily burning” or “hot grease”

Usual source. Anti-seize compound, penetrating oil or lubricant on bolts and threads, or oil residues on a newly handled part. It can also be a sign of oil in the exhaust path, for example from an engine-side oil leak.

Typical duration. A day or two of running. Mild smoke at hot parts may appear at first.

Check. Whether lubricant was used at the flanges and whether any dripped onto hot surfaces. If the smell grows stronger over days, or oily residue appears at drains or the outlet, suspect oil in the exhaust. See engine oil consumption and RECD suitability and RECD regeneration after wet stacking.

“Raw diesel” or “unburnt fuel”

Usual source. Unburnt fuel in the exhaust. After service, this can be from a fuel leak, from a start with rich combustion, from a set that has idled at light load or from work on the engine’s fuel system during the visit.

Typical duration. A brief smell on starting may be normal. A smell that persists at steady load is not.

Check. Fuel lines and connections touched during the visit, any smoke colour and the load pattern. A persistent raw-fuel smell with white smoke suggests the engine is not burning cleanly. See why a generator emits white smoke. If you can see liquid fuel anywhere, shut down and treat it as a fire risk.

“Hot, acrid” during regeneration

Usual source. The regeneration cycle itself. Burning soot and the very high temperatures reached during a regeneration produce a hot, sharp smell. A UK motoring organisation notes that a hot, acrid smell from the exhaust can accompany active regeneration, and a US vehicle-maker bulletin states that regeneration temperatures can create an odour noticeable outside or inside the vehicle. A stationary RECD follows the same physics.

Typical duration. For the length of the cycle and a little after it. The first regeneration after cleaning or core replacement is often the most noticeable, because the filter may contain residues or a heavier soot load.

Check. Whether a cycle is running, or ran recently, in the log. If the smell fades as the cycle ends, it was the regeneration. If the smell comes with heavy smoke or abnormal temperatures, see black smoke after RECD installation and interpreting an RECD regeneration completion message.

“Sweet” or “syrupy”

Usual source. Coolant. A sweet smell can mean coolant is leaking into the exhaust (for example through a failed gasket, cracked head or cooler) or onto hot parts. It can also follow engine work where coolant was spilled.

Typical duration. If it comes from spillage, it fades within hours. If it is a leak, it persists and is accompanied by coolant loss and white vapour.

Check. Coolant level and any loss since the visit, white vapour, wet or sticky deposits at drains and the outlet. Coolant in the exhaust can damage a filter and poison a catalyst, as described in our article on catalyst poisoning in an RECD. Treat a confirmed leak as urgent and raise it with the engine specialist.

“Damp and musty” or “wet ash”

Usual source. Moisture in insulation, canning or the filter, from cleaning, rain or condensate. When the system warms, the moisture evaporates and carries a smell of wet ash or musty fibre.

Typical duration. The first warm-ups, then gone.

Check. Whether the filter was washed and dried, whether insulation got wet during the visit and whether the plant room admits rain. See protecting an RECD against rainwater and condensation. A smell that persists beyond a week suggests continuing moisture ingress.

“Burning plastic” or “hot electrical”

Usual source. Cable insulation or a connector overheating, a cable too close to a hot pipe, a heater supply with a loose terminal or an overloaded circuit. A new sensor cable laid against a hot surface can also produce a mild plastic smell in the first hours, but a strong or growing electrical smell is a warning.

Typical duration. A faint plastic smell from a freshly installed part may fade within hours. Anything else should be treated as active.

Check. Cable routes near hot surfaces, heater breaker and terminals, discolouration on cable sheaths and insulation. See RECD cable routing near hot exhaust lines and RECD controller and heater power supply requirements. If the smell is strong, stop the heater, isolate and inspect before running again.

“Ordinary exhaust” stronger than before

Usual source. A leak that was created or worsened during the visit, such as a reused gasket, an unevenly tightened flange or a door not seated. A stronger exhaust smell in the room, particularly near a joint, points here.

Check. Immediately look for soot streaks and listen for ticking. See exhaust leaks around an RECD. Because carbon monoxide has no smell, ventilate and treat any suspected leak as a safety matter.

“Less smell than before”

Usual source. A working filter and catalyst can reduce some odour compounds. A noticeably reduced smell after a service may be genuine improvement, particularly if the catalyst was renewed or the filter cleaned. See can an RECD reduce diesel exhaust odour.

Check. Do not treat a reduced smell as proof of performance. If you need to know, measure.

The timeline: first hour, first day, first week

How long a smell lasts is as informative as what it smells like. The table below gives a rough guide for typical service work. If your supplier or manual gives different figures for your device, use theirs.

Time after serviceNormalRecheckAct now
First hour of runningHot metal, paint, light burnt dust, mild chemical from new partsStrong chemical smell, visible vapourRaw fuel smell with liquid, electrical burning smell, heavy smoke
First dayFading burn-off smells, hot acrid smell during a regenerationSame smell as hour one, no fading; oily smell growingPersisting sweet coolant smell with coolant loss, exhaust smell in the plant room
First weekOccasional faint smell on first start after long idleAny steady smell that is not fading; recurring damp smellSmell with alarms, rising ΔP, smoke change or temperature anomalies
Beyond one weekNothing newAny smell without a clear causeAny of the “act now” signs

Two habits make this table work in practice. First, note the time of the first noticed smell, the time of the first run and the load. Second, compare each run with the previous one, because “fading” is the most reassuring word in the whole process.

How to investigate, step by step

A short routine for anyone responsible for the set after a service.

  1. Get the change list. Ask for the service report and the list of materials used.
  2. Describe the smell in plain words, using the dictionary, and note where it is strongest. A smell strongest at the canister, at the silencer, at the heater cabinet or in the room tells you different things.
  3. Check the log. Was a regeneration running? What was the load? Any alarms since the visit?
  4. Look and listen with the system safe. Soot streaks, drips, discolouration, damp insulation, ticking.
  5. Compare readings. ΔP, temperatures and engine data at the same load against pre-service values. A change in readings with a smell strengthens the case for a real fault.
  6. Run it again under supervision. A loaded run of an hour or more, with a note at each stage. Smells that fade confirm burn-off.
  7. Decide: wait and watch, recheck a specific item or call the service company. Write the decision and the reason in the log.

Questions to put to the service engineer

A short list of questions gets you the information you need and shows the provider that you track the work.

  • What was removed, cleaned, replaced or lubricated, and with what?
  • What cleaning method and chemicals were used on the filter, and how was it dried?
  • Were new gaskets used at every joint that was opened, and what type?
  • Were any sealants or anti-seize products used, and where?
  • Was insulation removed or replaced?
  • Was anything done to the engine, fuel system or cooling system on the same visit?
  • Was a regeneration run after the service, and what did the log show?
  • What smells or smoke should we expect, and for how long?
  • What is the signal that we should call you back?

Our guide on what to record for an RECD warranty claim shows how a clear record helps if a mistake does turn out to have been made, and third-party service companies maintaining RECDs covers how to set expectations with an outside provider.

A worked illustration: one smell, three outcomes

The following is an illustrative scenario, not a real customer. A food-processing plant has its 400 kVA set’s RECD cleaned and its flange gaskets replaced. By the next morning, three people in different parts of the site notice a smell.

Operator 1 reports a “burnt, chemical” smell when the set starts for a test run, strongest at the canister. It fades within about forty minutes of loaded running and is much fainter on the second run. The service report shows that the filter was cleaned with a liquid process and dried in an oven, and that a high-temperature sealant was applied on one flange. The smell fits residues and sealant cure. The team records it, runs a second loaded session and the smell is gone by the third run.

Operator 2 reports a “sweet” smell from the stack side and white vapour at start. The coolant tank is slightly down since the visit, when the engine team also changed a hose. A coolant leak is suspected and the engine specialist finds a loose hose clamp dripping coolant onto the exhaust manifold. The clamp is tightened, the spill cleaned and the smell disappears. The RECD was not at fault, but the check prevented coolant from reaching the filter.

Operator 3 reports an “ordinary exhaust” smell in the plant room, stronger than before, plus a faint ticking at idle. A cold inspection shows a fresh soot streak at the RECD outlet flange, where the gasket was replaced. The gasket had been fitted slightly off-centre and the bolts were unevenly tightened. After a cold re-torque and a corrected gasket, the smell and the ticking stop. During the delay the team ventilated the plant room and limited running.

Three people smelled something after the same visit. Because the team asked “what was changed?” each time, the three outcomes were treated differently: wait and watch, fix the engine side and fix the joint.

What a smell should not make you do

  • Do not rely on smell for safety. Carbon monoxide is odourless.
  • Do not mask the smell with air fresheners or fans and call the matter closed.
  • Do not add fuel or oil additives in the hope of changing the smell.
  • Do not open the canister to look for the cause unless the supplier has told you how.
  • Do not repeat regeneration cycles repeatedly to “burn off” a smell. If a smell does not fade after a normal loaded run, find out why.
  • Do not ignore a smell that matches an “act now” description, however busy the day.

Frequently asked questions

Is a burning smell after servicing normal?

A mild burning or hot-metal smell for the first few hours of running is common, as new parts, coatings, sealants and residues burn off. If it fades with each run, it is probably burn-off. If it persists or grows, investigate.

Why does the smell get stronger when the set is under load?

Higher load raises temperatures and flow, which drives off more residue and moves more exhaust. If the smell is strongest at the first loaded run and weaker after, that is burn-off. If it is strong at every high load and fixed at one spot, suspect a leak.

Can a regeneration smell be dangerous?

The smell itself is a sign that soot is burning at high temperature. It is unpleasant and usually brief. Make sure the exhaust is vented outdoors and that the plant room is ventilated. Hazards come from leaks, smoke and unexpected heat, not from the smell alone.

Could the new smell mean the filter was damaged during service?

It is possible but not typical. Damage shows more reliably in readings such as falling ΔP, in smoke or in sounds than in smell. See rattling inside an RECD for noise-related signs.

How long should I wait before calling the service company?

If a smell fits the “normal” column and fades, there is no need to call. If it fits the “recheck” column after a day, call to ask about materials and the drying step. If it fits “act now”, call immediately and stop running if that is safe.

Bringing it together

A different smell after a service visit usually traces back to something done during the visit. Write the change list, match the smell to the dictionary, watch how it changes over the first hour, day and week and compare the readings. Mild burn-off smells that fade are normal. Smells that persist, intensify or come with readings, smoke, leaks or alarms need a recheck, and a few smells need action at once.

If you would like help writing a post-service checklist or deciding what an RECD service report should include, see our retrofit emission control devices, the FAQ or contact the Aceget team.

Related Reading

Sources



Leave a Reply